Skip to main content

Performative Discipline: Conformity at its finest

Good day, my love bugs.

My content this year is to do more research into the wellness space and debunk some things that are being presented as the truth or the only way for us to embark on our wellness journey. I see a lot of wellness content on my algorithm I also follow wellness focused content creators. One thing I have noticed especially when it comes to advice on finances is this strict ‘not spending’ financial routine that will save everyone money. However, there are people who are picking themselves up from the bootstrap, paying off student debt and companies not paying people well in general. I hope the intention behind the financial advice is good and maybe that is how these creators get by but this is just one example. I want to speak about wellness routines.

Performative discipline especially on social media in the context of the wellness industry, is a growing phenomenon. It refers to how people showcase their self-control, routines and commitment to health or productivity not just as personal practices but as curated performances for public consumption. This can include the daily 5 AM morning routine, clean eating and fitness meal preps, hustle culture posts, digital detoxes and minimalism challenges. There is no way we all have the same routine, have the same hobbies and are eating the same food! This performance is often aestheticized and idealised, blurring the line between genuine well-being and branding self-discipline as virtue or worth. I am more critical of this leading to self-punishment.

Michael Foucault a philosopher and political theorist often focused on disciplinary power which describes how modern societies control people not by force but by encouraging them to regulate themselves known as internalizing discipline. Think of when you are doing something and someone is watching you. Your behaviour is different when you are doing something alone versus when you know someone is watching you. Social media platforms extend this disciplinary power. How? Well, people document their productivity, fitness and wellness to show they are “good subjects” organised, controlled, worthy. The act of sharing becomes a performance of self-surveilliance.

In The Aftermath of Feminism Angela McRobbie argues that popular culture encourages women to embrace empowerment through consumption, self-discipline and personal responsibility but in ways that are apolitical and individualized. For example, wellness has become a personal makeover project not a collective response to structural issues like stress, inequality or misogyny. Feminism is then repackaged as lifestyle rather than a collective action or critique, feminism is often reduced to ‘girlboss’ rhetoric or Instagram affirmations, promoting hustle and healing as aesthetic and moral duties.

There is a new ideal woman and she identifies as confident, entrepreneurial, self-managing, stylish and productive. This woman is always working on herself in body, mind and brand and is seen as empowered but in a way that serves capitalism. Again there is nothing wrong with women working on themselves but we have to evaluate whether we doing this for us or for an idealized version of us that we will never attain. Both Focuault and McRobie highlight how self-surveillance and disciplinary norms are embedded in modern life and by extension in curated wellness routines online.

The consequences of perfornative discipline are that it is burnout masked as achievement. It also creates a comparison culture and shame for those who cannot meet these standards. The engagement we have with wellness then becomes superficial focusing on aesthetics and optics over genuine health or rest. This does nothing for mental health. Life is already tough as it is. This affects women more due to societal expectations of women to be “put together”, emotionally available and always improving. Wellness isn’t about punishment or proving worth. We all need to define wellness on our own terms.

In closing, discipline should be gentle, not brutal. Self-care should feel like coming home, not like performance anxiety in disguise.

Citations

Stein, M. (2016).Michel Foucault, Panopticism and Social Media. ResearchGate.

Ilmanen, A. (2023). Foucault, social media and climate change deniers: Disciplining abnormality through internet memes. Medium

Rogan, F.,(2024) “Evolving Notions of Consumption, “Influencing” and Postfeminist Femininity in Digital Cultures: A Perspective Piece”, Global Storytelling: Journal of Digital and Moving images.




Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The smart to average kid pipeline

My inspiration for this post came from a YouTube video titled ' You were a gifted kid 7 years ago. Now what?' by David Achu, I will link it down below. I won't toot my horn but I was a pretty smart kid. I got most of the awards in primary school and early on in high school. Being smart was my brand until fast forward to late high school and varsity. I know I am not the only one who has had this experience so let's take a lot into the dynamic of being a smart kid, overachiever, or even a child genius. You are not smart, you score well. The public school system in South Africa is focused more on feeding information to children rather than teaching students. The teachers are under pressure, schools are overcrowded and resources are limited. So, the system bases which children are bright on who can memorize the most information and who can get the highest scores. I mean scores do matter, APS/GPA matter and it also determines what you study in the future and...
Post a Comment
Read more

We may have to do this again

Good day, my love bugs. What if I told you that healing is not linear? What if I told you that there is not one big jackpot at the end? What if I told you that just as unpredictable as life is, so is healing? There are no incentives in the healing journey just reflection. At times healing feels like regression and can feel like a cycle of feeling immense contentment and hopelessness. So will the journey ever come to an end? I am still figuring it out but here are some tips about the healing journey you want to know. You are not better than anyone because you embarked on a healing journey. There is a sense of superiority that ‘pop psychology’ can give you which is going to be the downfall of mental health awareness. You should by all means share your good experiences with other people and even encourage people to embark on their healing journeys. However, you do not get to tell anyone that they are less than you or even look down on someone who is not on the same journey as you. Our jou...
Post a Comment
Read more

Keep sane this festive

Good day, my love bugs. It is the festive season, and most people spend time with loved ones. Home is not also a place that many people look forward to, and if you have made the decision to spend this festive season by yourself, I am proud of you. Here are some useful tips for taking care of your mental health during the festive season 1. Set realistic expectations Am I the only one who feels like the feeling of the festive season has changed over the years? Do not conform to the pressure to create a holiday spirit or to have as good a festive season as the previous years. If we are also keeping it a buck, the holiday spirit that everyone celebrates is mostly created by women in the family who labor for it. Try focusing on the moments that matter most. By setting realistic expectations you relieve yourself from stress and pressure 2. Practice self-care Do not neglect your self-care routine during the holidays, considering that you have spent the majority of the year working on it. Cont...
Post a Comment
Read more